Butt plugs: sizes, shapes and materials for a first plug and beyond
For a first butt plug, pick silicone with a widest point of about 2.5 to 3 cm, an insertable length under 9 cm and a flared base. If you have no idea which size suits you, a training set with two or three sizes saves you guessing. Glass and metal plugs come after that, for weight and temperature, and vibrating or rotating plugs make most sense once a plain plug already feels comfortable.
How to start with anal play is covered in anal play for beginners; this page compares the plugs.
The two numbers that decide the size
Widest point (diameter). This is what you feel on the way in. Makers often write a plug as length x width, so 7.5 x 2.5 cm means 2.5 cm at the thickest part. Under 3 cm counts as small, 3 to 4 cm as medium, and above 4 cm as large.
Insertable length. The part that goes inside, without the base. Short plugs of 6 to 9 cm sit at the entrance, where most of the nerve endings are. Longer plugs are felt as depth and fullness.
For metal and glass, weight counts too: a heavy plug makes itself felt when you stand up and walk.
The best butt plugs by situation
- Smallest silicone plug to start with: Chisa Butt Plug 7.5 x 2.5 cm. Soft silicone, 30 grams and 2.5 cm at the widest.
- Easiest to take out: Chisa Candy Plug Size S. 7.1 by 2.54 cm with a ring base you hook a finger through. The same plug also comes in size M (3.3 cm) and size L (4 cm) for later.
- Cheapest way to try vibration: Pretty Love Wyatt. Soft silicone, only 2.7 cm wide, ten patterns on one AA battery.
- Best training set in silicone: AfterDark Trinity Set of 3. The same tapered shape in S, M and L, with insertable lengths of 7, 11 and 12 cm and widths of 2.6, 3.4 and 4.6 cm.
- Training set with a vibrating last step: Bathmate Set of 4 Training Plugs. Four rising sizes, each with a finger loop, plus a bullet with ten patterns for the largest plug.
- Best small jewel plug: Chisa Rainbow Heart Size S. Aluminium alloy, 7.1 by 2.7 cm and 54 grams, with a heart stone in the base.
- Best glass plug for a beginner: Icicles No. 47. Glass of 2.8 cm across with 9.1 cm insertable, slim enough for a first try.
- Short glass plug that fits a harness: Icicles No. 90. 6.5 cm goes in, 3.5 cm at the widest, and the silicone base comes off or stays on for use in a harness.
- Best app plug for couples: Satisfyer Sweet Seal. A firm core under a soft coating, twelve vibration patterns, IPX7 and an app so your partner holds the controls.
- For rotation as well as vibration: Satisfyer Rotator Plug 2+. Twelve vibration and twelve rotation settings from balls inside the shaft, run on separate motors, with a whisper mode in the app.
- Remote control for a partner: Chisa Spiral Butt Plug. A ridged spiral of 4.4 cm at the widest and ten patterns on a wireless remote. Not a first plug.
- For gradual stretch beyond a plain plug: Master Series Inflatable Anal Plug. Goes in at 3.6 cm and is pumped up inside, to 6.35 cm if you want all of it, with a valve that lets the air out at once.
Butt plugs compared
| Plug | Material | Widest point | Length | Extra |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chisa 7.5 x 2.5 | Silicone | 2.5 cm | 7.5 cm total | 30 g |
| Chisa Candy S | Silicone and ABS | 2.54 cm | 7.1 cm total | Ring base |
| Pretty Love Wyatt | Silicone | 2.7 cm | 11.5 cm total | 10 patterns, AA |
| AfterDark Trinity | Silicone | 2.6, 3.4, 4.6 cm | 7, 11, 12 cm insertable | 3 sizes |
| Bathmate Set of 4 | Silicone | Not stated | Not stated | 4 sizes, bullet |
| Chisa Rainbow Heart S | Aluminium alloy | 2.7 cm | 7.1 cm total | 54 g, jewel |
| Icicles No. 47 | Glass | 2.8 cm | 9.1 cm insertable | Any lubricant |
| Icicles No. 90 | Glass | 3.5 cm | 6.5 cm insertable | Removable base |
| Satisfyer Sweet Seal | Silicone and ABS | Not stated | Not stated | App, IPX7 |
| Satisfyer Rotator 2+ | Silicone | Not stated | Not stated | Rotation, app |
| Chisa Spiral | Silicone and ABS | 4.4 cm | 10.9 cm total | Remote, IPX6 |
| Master Series Inflatable | Silicone | 3.6 to 6.35 cm | 8.9 cm insertable | Hand pump |
These are the makers' figures; not stated means the product page gives no number.
Shape: tapered, bulb and the neck
Tapered. The plug widens gradually from a narrow tip, like a cone. You control how far the stretch goes simply by how deep you push, which is why most training sets use this shape.
Bulb or teardrop. The classic plug. The widest part comes in the middle, then the plug narrows sharply into a neck before the base. You feel the moment the bulb passes, after which the muscles close around the neck and the plug stays put on its own. That holding effect is why people wear a bulb plug for longer.
Slim, long plugs are felt as depth rather than stretch, and spirals or ridges add sensation in and out; both are for later.
Whatever the shape, a butt plug needs a flared base, a ring or a T-shaped stop that stays outside the body. The rectum can draw objects in, and a toy without a stop can end up where you cannot reach it. Never use anything anal that lacks that base.
Silicone, glass or metal
Silicone is where most people begin. It is soft, warms to body temperature and gives a little at the widest point. Only use water-based lubricant with it, because silicone lubricant can damage silicone toys.
Glass is hard, smooth and holds warmth or coolness from a bowl of water for a while. It is non-porous, so it cleans completely and takes any lubricant. Check the surface for chips or cracks before each use and stop using a plug that has any.
Metal, usually aluminium alloy, is the heaviest choice and can also be warmed or cooled first. If you react to nickel, look for plugs described as nickel free.
PVC and TPE (also sold as T-Skin) are soft and cheaper, but porous. Wash them after every use and put a condom over them when you share. More in the body-safe materials guide.
Jewel plugs, vibrating plugs and plugs for couples
A jewel plug is a regular plug, mostly metal, with a stone in the base to look at and hold. Start with size S, because metal does not give.
Vibrating plugs carry a motor in the shaft or base. Rechargeable models with IPX7 can go in the bath and under the tap; IPX6 only means splashes. App and remote models are for couples: one person wears it, the other changes the pattern. A vibrating plug slides out more easily, so a clear neck helps.
Lube, wearing time and taking it out
Lube is not optional for anal play, because the anus does not get wet by itself. Use more than you think and add more halfway. Pjur Backdoor Water-Based is safe with every silicone plug. For glass and metal you can also use a silicone lubricant such as Eros Anal Base Silicone, which lasts longer and stays on in the shower; keep it away from silicone toys. More choice in anal lubricants and in our lubricant guide.
Start with ten to twenty minutes and build up over several sessions. Take the plug out straight away if it hurts, aches or goes numb. To remove it, breathe out, relax and pull slowly by the base while you bear down gently. Rinsing beforehand with lukewarm water is a personal choice; bulbs and showers are under douches and enemas.
Cleaning and storing
- Before and after each use: wash with warm water and mild soap or a toy cleaner, then let the plug dry completely.
- Glass and metal: can be boiled if you want to be sure, but let glass cool down slowly.
- Vibrating plugs: close the charging port or keep it dry, and take out any loose bullet before washing.
- Storage: keep silicone plugs apart from each other, and deflate an inflatable plug fully with the valve open.
Our full range is under butt plugs. Sets in several sizes are in anal starter toys, and if you want something you pull out bead by bead, see anal beads.
Frequently asked questions
What size butt plug should a beginner buy?
Silicone, 2.5 to 3 cm at the widest, under 9 cm insertable, with a flared base. Unsure? A set with several sizes.
What is the difference between a tapered and a bulb plug?
A tapered plug widens gradually and is easiest to control. A bulb plug narrows into a neck after its widest point, so it stays in by itself.
How long can I wear a butt plug?
Start with ten to twenty minutes and build up from there. Take it out as soon as it hurts, aches or goes numb.
Which lube goes with a silicone butt plug?
A water-based lubricant. Silicone lubricant can damage silicone toys; it is fine with glass and metal plugs.
Are glass and metal butt plugs safe?
Yes, both are non-porous. Check glass for chips first, and pick nickel-free metal if nickel bothers your skin.
Why does a butt plug need a flared base?
The base stops the plug from slipping all the way in. Never use any toy for anal play that has no flared base, ring or T-shaped stop.
Produtos deste guia

Plug anal Chisa em silicone 7.5 x 2.5 cm (preto)

Chisa Candy Plug Size S plug anal rosa

Pretty Love Wyatt plug anal com 10 modos de vibração (rosa)

AfterDark Trinity conjunto de 3 plugs anais (S, M, L)

Bathmate conjunto de 4 plugs de treino anal

Chisa Rainbow Heart Plug Anal Tamanho S

Icicles plug anal n.º 47

